Is Massachusetts Mike's a good spot for families with kids?

Absolutely — this is a casual, welcoming joint that families love. Kids thrive here because the vibe is energetic and laid-back, the pizza is legitimately great (not just kid-friendly as a consolation), and the service staff brings genuine warmth to every table.

Do I need a reservation or can I just walk in?

Walk-ins are welcome and the spot handles them well, but calling ahead is smart if you're bringing a larger group — one reviewer called ahead to ask about their gluten-free protocols and got excellent service. This is the kind of place that takes care of people who check in first.

What should I order on my first visit?

Start with a couple slices of pepperoni with jalapeños (reviewers specifically praise this combo for the heat and flavor), then branch into the BBQ chicken pizza if you want something different. The crust is consistently described as crunchy even after the pizza cools down — that's the hallmark of their technique.

Can you accommodate gluten-free diets here?

Yes — they offer 12-inch gluten-free pizzas with gluten-free crust, and the staff is genuinely knowledgeable about handling them safely for people with Celiac disease. Call ahead with your questions like other diners do; they're prepared and happy to help.

Is there outdoor seating in Hillcrest?

Yes, this spot has outdoor seating available, which is perfect for catching some air while you eat. It's a solid option for nice weather, though specific details on patio size and setup should be confirmed when you visit.

What's the vibe like — is this a casual weeknight spot or more upscale?

It's pure casual weeknight energy: neighborhood staple, friendly staff (the owner is hands-on and present), and fair prices that won't break the bank. Don't come looking for white tablecloths; come for legitimately excellent pizza and the kind of service that makes you want to become a regular.

Do they have vegetarian options?

Yes, vegetarian options are available on the menu. The pizza-forward approach means you can build custom pies with all the toppings you want, so vegetarians eat as well here as everyone else.

Massachusetts Mike's Pizzeria — Restaurants in Hillcrest, S…

“Massachusetts Mike's Pizzeria does the thing most University Avenue spots won't: sell you a single slice with actual crust integrity.”

Where Snooze engineers pancake flights for indecisive brunch tables and Goi Cuon runs a full vegetarian pho program, Mike's operates on New England pizza logic—thin crust, crisp undercarriage, slices big enough to fold, sold individually or as whole pies without the ceremonial wait. It's the rare Hillcrest spot where you can grab one slice on your way to the farmers market Sunday or feed six people without a reservation. The differentiator is structural: that crust stays crunchy even after it cools, a detail that separates weekend pizza from actual pizza.

The two-slice deal runs all day and pulls regulars who live within three blocks—pepperoni with jalapeños gets the most repeat orders, BBQ chicken shows up for tables splitting pies. The kitchen handles gluten-free requests with enough care that Celiac customers call ahead and actually get answers, not deflection. It's 12-inch pies only, vegan crust, cooked in dedicated space. That's not common for a $3-slice operation.

Mike (the owner, present most nights) runs the kind of energy that makes the sign feel redundant—you know it's his place within thirty seconds of walking in. June at the front counter matches that vibe. The garlic knots operate as the unofficial appetizer; most two-tops order them without looking at the menu. Outdoor seating spills onto University Avenue, which works until the Friday dinner rush when tables fill and the wait goes from zero to twenty minutes.

This is the neighborhood's casual-weeknight anchor, the spot that doesn't require planning or pants that button. It's not craft pizza, not Neapolitan theater—it's the joint that feeds Hillcrest locals who want a slice that works cold the next morning.