Is there parking at Gnarly Girl Pizza in University Heights?

Street parking is available on El Cajon Blvd and surrounding areas, though it can be tight during peak dinner hours. Plan to arrive a few minutes early to scout a spot, or consider going during lunch when turnover is faster.

How long is the wait on a typical visit?

Lunch tends to move quickly with minimal waits, but dinner — especially weekends — can stretch to 45+ minutes. Go early (before 5:30pm) or call ahead to gauge the crowd; it's worth timing your visit around their busier periods.

What pizza should I order first?

Start with the Controversy or PBJ if you want something adventurous, but their classic 18-inch NY pepperoni is genuinely solid. The pizzas run loaded with toppings, so don't sleep on the vegetarian options either — they take those seriously.

Is Gnarly Girl good for kids?

Absolutely. The Ninja Turtles theme and playful vibe make it a natural fit for families, and picky eaters have had real success here. Just expect it to be louder and more chaotic during peak hours, which can be either a plus or a minus depending on your mood.

Do they have vegetarian options?

Yes — vegetarian options are strong here and not an afterthought. Between their sauce quality and creative toppings, meat-free slices hold their own against the loaded meat pizzas.

Can I order by the slice or do I need a whole pizza?

You can grab slices, which is perfect for lunch or testing the menu. This also means you can get in and out faster during busy times without committing to a full pie.

What's the vibe like — is it a casual spot or more of a date destination?

It works both ways. The nostalgic Ninja Turtles murals and fun, casual atmosphere make it great for group dinners or low-key dates, but service can be inconsistent when they're slammed, so manage expectations on busier nights.

Gnarly Girl Pizza — Restaurants in University Heights, San…

“Gnarly Girl Pizza is University Heights' unapologetically goofy slice joint where Ninja Turtles nostalgia meets actual New York-style crust — no frills, just loaded pies and a vibe that makes zero apologies.”

Where Stella Jean's leans on craft execution and Loving Hut polishes plant-based comfort food, Gnarly Girl operates in a different gear entirely: chunky slices, murals of Leonardo and Donatello, and a kitchen that prioritizes toppings over table service. This is the spot where your kid eats pepperoni off a paper plate while you tackle the **Controversy** — a slice so loaded with ingredients it barely holds structural integrity, which is half the point.

The **PBJ** sounds like a dare until you taste it — sweet-savory chaos that works better than it has any right to. The **Fred Flinstone** (name suggests meat, reviews confirm heft) shows up in mentions as a regular order, which tells you it's reliable fuel for groups splitting pies. The **Buffalo Chicken Fries** lean heavy on the fries, light on the toppings — more bar snack than entrée, but at this price point nobody's filing complaints.

Service runs slow when it gets busy, sometimes stretching to 45 minutes for an 18-inch pie, and the space could use a deeper clean between rushes. But the pizza itself — good sauce, proper char on the crust, pepperoni that curls at the edges — delivers what you came for. The beer selection covers the basics, the outdoor seating lets you people-watch El Cajon Boulevard, and the whole operation feels like it was built for Tuesday nights when you don't want to think too hard.

Park on the boulevard or the surrounding blocks. Order at the counter, grab a beer, don't expect table service. If you're solo, the slice counter moves faster than full pies. If you're bringing kids, the Ninja Turtles theme buys you 20 minutes of goodwill.

Gnarly Girl Pizza

FAQ

Google Reviews

BonVivant Reviews

Similar Spots

Hatsuzakura

SOICHI

Kaffa Coffee

Complementary Spots

Donna Jean

SOICHI

Contact & Hours